Many coffee fans visiting Italy ask the same thing: what is the difference between an espresso and an Americano in Italy? The short answer is simple: espresso is the core of Italian coffee, a small, strong shot made for quick enjoyment. An Americano is the same espresso stretched with hot water, giving a bigger, milder drink. To really see the difference, it helps to look a little closer. It’s not just about adding water; it’s also about history, habits, taste, and daily routine.
Italian coffee culture values tradition and simple, high-quality drinks. You won’t see giant flavored drinks on every street, except maybe at an airport chain. The standard order is espresso, the base for many Italian coffee drinks. The Americano exists for visitors who want something closer to drip coffee. Below, you’ll see how these two drinks differ and how they fit into daily life in Italy.
Espresso and Americano: What Sets Them Apart in Italy?
Coffee Origins and Definitions
Italian espresso started in the late 1800s. Angelo Moriondo patented a steam-based machine, which led to later designs. In 1901, Luigi Bezzera created a better machine that used high-pressure water. Desiderio Pavoni helped spread the idea, and small coffee bars became part of Italian life. Espresso is a method: very hot water pushed through fine coffee at about 9 bars of pressure. In seconds, it makes about 1 ounce of dark coffee with a layer of crema on top.
The Americano has a different story. During World War II, American soldiers in Italy wanted coffee like what they had at home. Italian espresso was too strong for some of them, so they added hot water to it. That drink became known as “caffè Americano.” It’s a shot of espresso mixed with hot water. Both drinks use espresso as the base, but their origins and purpose are different.
Key Differences in Italian Coffee Bars
In Italy, a “bar” is a small place that serves coffee, snacks, and drinks. These bars are often family-run and follow long-held habits. If you ask for “Un caffè per favore,” you will get an espresso. That is the default in almost every bar.
An Americano is available, but it isn’t the usual choice for locals. It is seen as a drink for visitors. It won’t come in a giant cup with free refills. It’s still a modest serving: espresso with added hot water. Coffee at the bar is quick-most people drink it standing and move on with their day.
How Are Espresso and Americano Made in Italy?
Traditional Italian Espresso Preparation
Making classic Italian espresso is a careful craft with set steps. Many blends mix Arabica and Robusta beans, with up to about 20% Robusta for extra bite and body. The grind is very fine, around 200-300 microns, which is needed for good extraction.
Brewing is fast. Water at about 90-94°C (194-201°F) runs through the packed coffee at roughly 9 bars of pressure. The pull takes about 25-30 seconds and uses around 7 grams of coffee to yield about 25 ml. A good espresso has a stable, creamy crema that carries a lot of the aroma and flavor.
How Caffè Americano Is Prepared in Italy
An Americano starts as a standard Italian espresso. What turns it into an Americano is hot water added to the finished shot. This lowers the intensity and increases the volume.
Ratios vary by bar, but the goal is a larger, milder drink, closer to drip coffee. In Italy, the water is added after the espresso is pulled. This is different from a caffè lungo, where more water runs through the grounds during brewing. An Americano is served in a bigger cup by Italian standards, though still smaller than many American servings.
Size, Strength, and Appearance: How Do These Coffees Compare?
Serving Size and Presentation Traditions
In Italy, size matters for coffee, and cups are small. A typical espresso is about 25 ml (1 ounce), served in a small ceramic cup that leaves room for crema. The setup is simple and focused on the drink. Most people finish it quickly while standing at the counter. Takeaway cups are rare; the moment is meant to be short.
An Americano is bigger than an espresso but still not huge. It comes in a regular cup, made larger by the hot water added to the shot. Even so, it stays modest in size. The idea is a slightly longer coffee moment, still in line with local habits. Long, milk-heavy drinks after morning hours are uncommon.
| Drink | Brew method | Typical volume | Texture | Flavor strength | Caffeine (1 shot) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Espresso | High-pressure extraction | ~25 ml | Thick, syrupy | Very strong | ~63 mg |
| Americano | Espresso + hot water | 120-180 ml (varies) | Lighter, thinner | Milder | ~63 mg per shot used |
Taste Profile and Strength Differences
Italian espresso tastes bold and layered. You might notice bitter, earthy, sweet, or fruity notes, thanks to the blend and the quick, high-pressure brew. The fine grind gives a dense, almost syrupy feel. Many Italians drink it “amaro” (without sugar) to enjoy the full, strong flavor. The crema adds aroma and a smooth finish.
An Americano is milder because it’s diluted with hot water. The same flavors are present, but they are spread out, and the body is lighter. If you like drip coffee, this will feel more familiar. It’s a good choice if straight espresso tastes too strong. You can add sugar if you like, or drink it plain.
Caffeine Content in Italian Espresso and Americano
How Much Caffeine Does Each Offer?
About caffeine: a 1-ounce espresso shot has around 63 mg of caffeine. Ounce for ounce, that’s strong compared with drip coffee, which sits around 12-16 mg per ounce.
An Americano uses one or more espresso shots plus hot water. The water does not add caffeine. One-shot Americano: about 63 mg. Two-shot Americano: about 126 mg. The size of the cup does not change the total amount of caffeine-only the number of shots does.
Does Diluting Espresso Affect Caffeine Levels?
No. Adding hot water spreads the espresso across a larger volume but does not change how much caffeine is in the cup. The caffeine comes out during the espresso pull.
An Americano may taste gentler because it is less concentrated, but a single-shot Americano gives you the same caffeine as a single espresso. The difference you feel comes from flavor intensity and serving size, not the stimulant level per shot.
Popular Variations on Espresso in Italian Cafés
Italian bars offer many espresso-based drinks. A caffè macchiato (“stained”) is an espresso with a small spoon of foamed milk. A caffè latte is espresso with more warm milk for a softer, milk-forward cup. Remember: ordering “latte” alone means you’ll get a glass of milk, since “latte” means milk in Italian.
In warm weather, you might find caffè freddo, which can be espresso shaken with ice and sugar or chilled sweetened espresso. Crema di caffè is a cold, semi-frozen coffee treat with a creamy texture. Affogato is dessert and coffee together: a scoop of gelato covered with a hot shot of espresso. All of these start with espresso and fit different tastes and times of day.
How Americano Differs from Caffè Lungo
Americano and lungo both give you more volume than a straight espresso, but they are made differently. An Americano is espresso first, then hot water added after brewing.
A lungo (“long”) runs extra water through the grounds during extraction. This longer pull brings out more soluble compounds and can add bitterness, with a thinner body than a standard espresso. A lungo is still served in a small cup, just with a bit more liquid than a regular shot. Americano gets bigger by dilution after brewing; lungo gets bigger during brewing, which changes the taste and feel.
Cultural Significance: Espresso vs Americano in Italian Daily Life
How Italians Drink Their Coffee
In Italy, coffee is a daily habit and a quick social pause. Many people start the day with an espresso or a cappuccino at the local bar. Most drink it standing at the counter and leave soon after. Sitting at a table often costs more.
People enjoy espresso many times in a day-mid-morning, after lunch, even after dinner. These small shots act as short breaks and moments to chat. Milk-based drinks like cappuccino and caffè latte are mostly morning drinks, usually before 11 am. Many Italians think hot milk later in the day is heavy on the stomach, so they avoid it after the morning.
Tourist Preferences and Local Perceptions
Visitors to Italy sometimes look for larger cups or flavored drinks. Many end up ordering a caffè Americano because it feels closer to drip coffee. Bars will make it, but locals view espresso as the true standard.
To many Italians, a coffee fan enjoys the strong punch of a straight espresso. An Americano is fine, but it doesn’t carry the same tradition. Trying espresso the local way can give you a more genuine taste of daily life in Italy.
How to Order Espresso and Americano in Italy
Common Phrases and Etiquette at Italian Coffee Bars
Ordering at an Italian coffee bar might feel confusing at first, but a few basics help a lot. A coffee shop is called a “bar.” Many bars use a pay-first system:
- Go to the cashier, say your order, and pay.
- Keep the receipt (“scontrino” or “ticket”).
- Give the receipt to the barista and get your drink.
Helpful phrases:
- “Un caffè, per favore!” – a single espresso
- “Un doppio, per favore!” – a double espresso
- “Un caffè Americano, per favore!” – an Americano
Most people drink at the counter (“al banco”). Sitting at a table (“al tavolo”) often costs more. You may get a small glass of water to cleanse your palate before the coffee. And remember, “latte” means milk-ask for “caffè latte” or “latte macchiato” if you want coffee with milk.
When to Choose Espresso or Americano in Italy
Pick espresso if you want the classic Italian experience. It works any time of day, is quick to drink, and gives a strong taste and lift. Many locals have several through the day-morning, after lunch, or mid-afternoon. As the saying goes, “Chi dice no ad un espresso?”
Choose an Americano if you prefer a bigger, milder cup, especially in the morning. It keeps the flavor of espresso but with less intensity. For a full taste of local habits, try an espresso “amaro” at least once. Both drinks are easy to find, so you can choose the style you like while respecting local customs.
What to Expect When Tasting Espresso and Americano in Italy
First-Time Experience with Italian Espresso
If it’s your first Italian espresso, expect a small cup with a big aroma. The liquid is dark, and a reddish-brown crema sits on top. That crema is a sign of a well-pulled shot and adds smooth texture and aroma.
Smell it first, then sip. The flavor is strong and concentrated, with notes that can be bitter, earthy, sweet, or fruity, based on the blend. The texture can feel thick and coating. Drink it in a few sips. You might get a small glass of water first to clean your palate so the flavors stand out. It’s a quick, focused coffee moment that shows how Italians enjoy their daily brew.
Leave a comment